You did everything right. You can still get sued.
Most small business owners think employment lawsuits happen to big companies. They don't. A former employee who feels they were let go unfairly, a job applicant who wasn't hired, or a team member who says a supervisor crossed a line can all bring a claim, whether or not it has merit.
Even a claim you win costs money to defend. Employment practices liability insurance (EPLI) is built for exactly that. It can help pay for your legal defense, plus settlements and judgments, when an employment-related claim is made against the business. Your general liability policy typically excludes these claims, so EPLI fills a real gap.
We're an independent agency, so we compare EPLI across several insurance companies. Some offer it as an endorsement to a Business Owners Policy and others write it as its own policy, and the difference can matter. Mark Goodwin has been a licensed insurance professional since 1990, and our offices in Marion and Powell work with employers throughout Ohio.