Ohio coverage that feels like home

An independent agency that shops multiple carriers for your home, auto, life and business insurance, so you don't have to. That's eGoodwin Insurance.

Get My Free Quote
Since 1990in the community
2 officesMarion & Powell
5.0
on Google (88 reviews)
A light stone family home with a wood-beam entry, shaded by mature trees
Trusted in Ohio since 1990

Local service, done right.

We're an independent agency, so we work for you, not an insurance company. Mark and Nikki shop your coverage across several carriers, explain your options in plain English, and stay with you from the first policy through every renewal.

5.0
88
Google reviews
1990
Serving since
2
Local offices
Independent, on purpose

One door, or 21. We open all of them for you.

A captive agent can quote one company. If its price or coverage doesn't fit, you start over somewhere else.We represent 21 companies. We compare them for you, then explain your options in plain English.

Watch us shop.

Here's what happens after you send us your ZIP: we compare the companies that fit, then walk you through real options, not just a price.

Sample household

Marion, OH 43302

  • 2 drivers
  • 2 cars
  • 1 home
  • Bundle: auto + home
Comparing across our 21 companies…0 / 21
  • Progressive
  • GEICO
  • Nationwide
  • Travelers
  • Safeco
  • Liberty Mutual
  • The Hartford
  • Hanover
  • National General
  • Branch
  • Openly
  • The General
  • Foremost
  • American Modern
  • 1859 Mutual
  • Millers Mutual
  • Berkshire Hathaway
  • Philadelphia
  • AmTrust
  • USLI
  • Hiscox

Lowest price

$$$

Meets your lender and Ohio law, with less room for a bad day.

Liability50/100/50
Uninsured motorist50/100
Deductible$1,000
  • Roadside
Our pick

Best value

$$$

The coverage we'd choose for this household, at a fair price.

Liability100/300/100
Uninsured motorist100/300
Deductible$500
  • Roadside
  • Rental car

Most protection

$$$

Highest limits, lowest deductibles, plus an umbrella quote.

Liability250/500/100
Uninsured motorist250/500
Deductible$250
  • Roadside
  • Rental car
  • Umbrella option

Sample options for an illustrative household, not a quote. Which companies can quote depends on your drivers, cars, home and ZIP, and your price will differ. GEICO is offered through GEICO's agency brokerage program.

Already a client? Pay a bill or report a claim →

eGoodwin Insurance helps protect the life you're building.

A bright, modern apartment living room
Apartments & Rentals

Renters Insurance

Your belongings, protected where you rent

A rental home with a For Rent sign in the front yard
Real Estate Investors

Landlord & Investors

Single-family, multifamily and apartment buildings

A local business team standing outside their Ohio storefront
For Business Owners

Business Insurance

Dental, medical and aesthetic offices, and more

Floodwater surrounding a stone house after heavy rain
Flash-Flood Smart

Flood Insurance

NFIP flood coverage. Homeowners policies don't cover flood

An older couple smiling together at home
Featured

Long-Term Care

Asset-based plans that pair life insurance with care benefits

More ways we protect you. Coverage built around real life.

We Shop For You

Several carriers.
One honest comparison.

We're independent, so we quote your coverage with multiple insurance companies, lay the options side by side, and help you choose. Then we keep shopping as the market changes.

1Carrier quote #1
Same coverage, compared
2Carrier quote #2
Same coverage, compared
Your pick, explained
Reviewed again at renewal
Bundling

One agency.
Better together.

Keep your home and auto in one place. We compare carriers for the pair, handle one review, and bundling may lower what you pay on both.

HHome Policy
Dwelling + liability
AAuto Policy
2 vehicles, full coverage
Bundled and covered
One agency · one review
Long-Term Care

Plan for care
before you need it.

Asset-based long-term care pairs life insurance or an annuity with care benefits. If care is never needed, a death benefit goes to your heirs. Learn how it works.

"What if one of us needs care someday?"
Care benefits built in
Life insurance or annuity based
$Care never needed?
A death benefit goes to heirs
Annual Review

Your life changes.
Your coverage should too.

New car, remodel, teen driver, new rental. Every year we re-check your coverage and discounts together, free.

"Finished the basement. Does the house need more coverage?"
Yearly review booked
With Mark or Nikki
Beyond the Minimums

The state minimum
isn't a plan.

Ohio's 25/50/25 rarely covers a serious crash on I-71 or US-23. Uninsured motorist coverage is optional here, and worth a look. We size coverage to what you have to protect.

25/50/25Ohio minimum
Covers less than most new cars cost
Your plansized to your life
Assets, family & lifestyle accounted for
Real Estate Investors

Rentals and apartments,
covered properly.

Single-family rentals, multifamily buildings and apartments: the structure, the rent, and the liability many owners miss.

RRental · Delaware
Dwelling + loss of rent
MFourplex · Marion
Added to the same review
$Landlord liability
The layer owners forget
New Homebuyers

Closing soon?
Let's get it done.

Lender-ready binders, escrow deadlines and proof of coverage, handled. One less thing between you and the keys.

"Closing is Friday. Lender needs proof of insurance!!"
Binder sent to lender
Before closing day
🔑Keys on Friday
Covered from day one
When It Happens

The day you
actually need us.

A real person who knows your policy, walks you through the claim, and follows up until it's settled. This is what you're actually buying.

!Fender bender · US-23
Everyone's okay
Claim started with you
On the phone, step by step
Followed to the finish
Check-ins until it's closed

Ballpark it. Then get your real number in one call.

Estimated Monthly Premium
$164
per month
Liability (25/50/25+)$66/mo
Collision$54/mo
Comprehensive$31/mo
Add-ons$11/mo
* Illustrative estimates only, not Ohio averages. Actual rates vary by carrier, driver, vehicle, home, coverage and ZIP. As an independent agency we compare several carriers. Bundling home + auto may lower what you pay.
Get My Quote →
Estimated Annual Premium
$2,860
per year ($238/mo)
Dwelling$150/mo
Personal Property$43/mo
Liability$29/mo
Other Structures$17/mo
* Illustrative estimates only, not Ohio averages. Actual rates vary by carrier, driver, vehicle, home, coverage and ZIP. As an independent agency we compare several carriers. Roof age, your deductibles and a water backup endorsement matter, and flood is always a separate policy.
Get My Quote →
Estimated Monthly Premium
$36
per month · level for the full term
Coverage$750,000
Rate per $100k$4.80/mo
Term20 years
Protection through age55
* Illustrative estimates only, not Ohio averages. Actual rates vary by carrier, age, health, term and coverage amount. As an independent agency we compare several carriers. Final rates depend on underwriting.
Get My Quote →

21 companies. One agent working for you.

  • ProgressiveProgressive
  • GEICOGEICO
  • NationwideNationwide
  • TravelersTravelers
  • SafecoSafeco
  • Liberty MutualLiberty Mutual
  • The HartfordThe Hartford
  • HanoverHanover
  • National GeneralNational General
  • BranchBranch
  • OpenlyOpenly
  • The GeneralThe General
  • ForemostForemost
  • American ModernAmerican Modern
  • 1859 Mutual1859 Mutual
  • Millers MutualMillers Mutual
  • Berkshire HathawayBerkshire Hathaway
  • PhiladelphiaPhiladelphia
  • AmTrustAmTrust
  • USLIUSLI
  • HiscoxHiscox
  • The GeneralThe General
  • ForemostForemost
  • American ModernAmerican Modern
  • 1859 Mutual1859 Mutual
  • Millers MutualMillers Mutual
  • Berkshire HathawayBerkshire Hathaway
  • PhiladelphiaPhiladelphia
  • AmTrustAmTrust
  • USLIUSLI
  • HiscoxHiscox
  • ProgressiveProgressive
  • GEICOGEICO
  • NationwideNationwide
  • TravelersTravelers
  • SafecoSafeco
  • Liberty MutualLiberty Mutual
  • The HartfordThe Hartford
  • HanoverHanover
  • National GeneralNational General
  • BranchBranch
  • OpenlyOpenly

What clients say. 5.0 stars across 88 Google reviews.

Joe G.Google review
“Great service. Great communication. Great people. Thanks Mark and Nikki!”
Niki M.Google review
“Our experience was seamless working with eGoodwin Insurance! Very informative and helpful.”
A smiling couple in front of a freshly painted navy blue wall, one standing on a step ladder with a paint roller
Howard Z.Google review
“Rates were fair and the staff is very responsive and informative.”
Gloria T.Google review
“I am very happy to recommend him as an extremely knowledgeable agent who gives great attention to detail.”
Read all 88 reviews on Google ↗

Ohio insurance questions. Straight answers.

Why is my homeowners insurance going up in Ohio?

Most increases have little to do with you and a lot to do with the weather and the cost of rebuilding. Severe spring and summer storms bring straight-line winds, hail and the occasional tornado. Winter freezes burst pipes. And the labor and materials needed to repair roofs and rebuild homes cost more than they used to. Those pressures push premiums up even for homeowners who have never filed a claim.

What you can control: your deductibles, bundling your home and auto, and making sure your dwelling limit matches what your home would actually cost to rebuild. And shopping. Because we're independent, we can compare several carriers at renewal instead of handing you one company's increase.

How do wind and hail deductibles work?

Some homeowners policies carry a separate wind/hail deductible. Instead of a flat dollar amount, it may be figured as a percentage of your dwelling coverage. For example, on a home insured for $300,000, a 1% wind/hail deductible would mean $3,000 out of pocket on a hail claim, even if your regular deductible is lower.

Not every policy has one, and terms vary by carrier. Your roof's age and material can also affect how a roof claim is paid, including whether it's settled at replacement cost or actual cash value. We'll show you where yours sits and what it would cost to change it.

Does homeowners insurance cover a flooded basement from a sump pump failure or sewer backup?

Usually not on its own. Standard homeowners policies usually exclude water that backs up through drains or overflows from a failed sump pump unless you add a water backup endorsement. For Ohio homes with finished basements, it's one of the most useful add-ons there is.

Water backup is different from flood. Backup coverage is for water coming up through your drains or sump. Flood insurance is for surface water rising from outside, like a creek over its banks. Condo owners and renters can add backup coverage too. We'll check whether your policy has it, and how much.

Do I need flood insurance in Ohio?

It's worth a serious look. A standard homeowners policy does not cover flood. Flood is a separate policy, and we can help you get coverage through the National Flood Insurance Program (NFIP).

Homes along the Olentangy and Scioto River corridors aren't the only ones at risk. Creeks like Alum Creek and Big Walnut Creek can rise fast in heavy rain, and flash flooding doesn't stop at flood-zone lines. NFIP policies generally have a 30-day waiting period before coverage starts, so don't wait for the forecast. If your home is in a high-risk flood zone (SFHA) and you have a mortgage, your lender will require flood coverage.

How much homeowners insurance do I need?

Enough to rebuild your home, not enough to rebuy it. Your dwelling limit should track the cost to reconstruct your house at today's labor and material prices, which has little to do with what you paid or what a listing site says it's worth.

Under-insuring is the common mistake, and it only shows up at the worst possible moment, like after a big storm when roofers and materials are in demand. We'll run the rebuild numbers with you.

Is Ohio's minimum auto coverage (25/50/25) enough?

Rarely. Ohio requires 25/50/25 liability limits: $25,000 for bodily injury per person, $50,000 per accident and $25,000 for property damage. Ohio is an at-fault state, so if you cause a serious crash on I-71 or US-23, medical bills and today's vehicle prices can outrun those limits fast, and you could owe the rest.

Uninsured/underinsured motorist coverage (UM/UIM) isn't required in Ohio. It's optional, and worth considering, because it protects you when the other driver can't pay. We size coverage to what you actually have to protect.

How can I lower my car insurance in Ohio?

Start by shopping. As an independent agency, we can quote your coverage with several carriers and compare, instead of offering one company's price. Then the usual levers: bundle your auto with your home, condo or renters policy, raise your deductible if you have savings to cover it, drop collision on a car that isn't worth much anymore, and make sure every discount you may qualify for is applied.

A paid-off car, a new driver, a move or a new commute can change what you pay, so we review it with you every year. What doesn't work is quietly cutting your liability limits. That may save a few dollars a month and exposes everything you own.

How much life insurance do I need?

A common rule of thumb is 10 to 12 times your annual income, but the better math is specific to you: what's left on the mortgage, what it would cost to raise and educate your kids, any debts that wouldn't disappear, and how many years your family would need income if you weren't here.

Term life is often more affordable than people expect. Try the life tab in our rate estimator to ballpark it, then ask us to compare term and permanent options across the carriers we represent.

What is asset-based long-term care insurance?

It's life insurance or an annuity with long-term care benefits built in or added by rider. It's often funded with a single premium or a limited number of payments. If you need care, the policy helps pay for it. If you never need care, a death benefit goes to your heirs.

That's different from traditional long-term care insurance, where premiums can rise over time and you "use it or lose it." The U.S. Department of Health and Human Services estimates someone turning 65 today has almost a 70% chance of needing some type of long-term care services. Learn more on our long-term care page. This is general information, not tax or legal advice.

What is umbrella insurance and do I really need it?

An umbrella policy adds liability protection on top of the limits in your home and auto policies, usually starting at $1 million. If you're found responsible for a serious accident and the claim exceeds your underlying limits, the umbrella picks up from there instead of your savings, your equity or your future wages.

For homeowners and real estate investors with assets to protect, it's often a cost-effective layer. Ask us whether an umbrella makes sense for you; it pairs naturally with a home and auto bundle.

What's the difference between condo insurance and homeowners insurance?

Your HOA's master policy generally covers the building's structure and shared areas. Your condo policy, an HO-6, covers what the master policy doesn't: your interior walls, floors, cabinets and fixtures, your belongings, your personal liability, and loss assessments the HOA can charge back to you.

The mistake is assuming the HOA has it handled. Read the master policy's limits, then insure the gap. We'll read it with you.

Why use an independent insurance agent?

An independent agency represents multiple insurance companies, not just one. That means we can shop your coverage across several carriers, compare price and coverage side by side, and recommend the best fit. We help you buy insurance rather than sell it to you, and we work for you, not an insurance company.

It also means you don't have to start over when your needs or the market change. Mark has been a licensed insurance professional since 1990, and we'll keep guiding you, from your first policy through every renewal.

Still have questions? Call (740) 387-8335. We'll give you a straight answer.

Ready when you are.
One call covers it all.

Home, auto, life, long-term care and business coverage from a local independent agency in Marion and Powell. We shop several carriers so you don't have to.

Two offices. Serving Ohio.

eGoodwin Insurance

📍
Marion office (main)
399 E. Church Street
Marion, OH 43302
📍
Powell office
74 E. Olentangy Street
Powell, OH 43065
📞
Phone
The fastest way to reach us
✉️
Email
Questions, quotes and policy changes
🕐
Hours
Mon – Fri: 9:00 AM – 5:00 PM Eastern
Sat – Sun: Closed